Is my dog secretly judging me?

Is my dog secretly judging me?

Short answer: probably. Long answer: also yes, but in a loving way where you are both their favorite person and their favorite sitcom.

Your dog stares when you put on pants that scream “laundry day.” They sigh when you forget walk time. They tilt their head when you say “we’re cutting back on snacks” like you just announced you hate joy. Is it judgment or are they just really good at face-acting?

SECTION: What “judging” looks like in dog

  • Eye contact that lingers a little too long

  • A single slow blink

  • The polite turn-away when you use the wrong nickname

  • The deep sigh before collapsing onto their bed like a tragic poet

Behavior translation: they read tone, routine, and body language. They notice inconsistent rules. They know the leash makes you happier. They know snacks make them happier.

SECTION: Why your dog seems judgy

  • Predictability is dog religion. If breakfast is 8 a.m. most days and noon on weekends, expect side-eye.

  • Energy mismatch. You have work brain. They have zoomie brain.

  • Snack economics. Too many treats equals couch potato cosplay. Too few treats equals union meeting in the kitchen.

SECTION: The fix that makes your dog less judgey and you more smug

  • Meet needs before manners: 10 to 15 minutes of walk or fetch, water, potty, then a calm “place” on a comfy bed just out of the way.

  • Pay tiny but mighty rewards: one or two pieces, or a small handful of broken bits across a session.

  • Rotate flavors so your dog stays engaged without overfeeding.

Shop the calm kit

SECTION: Signs the judgment is actually a problem

  • Pacing, panting, or whining at small routine changes

  • Guarding food or spaces

  • Startle-barking at every noise

  • Refusing to relax even after exercise
    If that’s your dog: tighten the routine, add more mental work, keep rewards tiny but frequent for quiet on the bed. If concerns stick, talk to your vet or a trainer.

SECTION: Day-in-the-life script

  • Morning: walk, water, breakfast, two minutes “place,” one tiny treat

  • Afternoon: snuffle game or short fetch, then chill

  • Evening: walk or play, gentle training with tiny treat bits, bedtime routine


Dogs aren’t petty. They are routine experts. Give them exercise, a comfy place, and tiny portions of clean, freeze-dried treats for the behaviors you want. Rotate flavors. The judgment face becomes the contented nap face.

 

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Recent Post

View all
1 3
View all